Safe, But Not Too Loud

Connective Parenting Blog

I’ve been thinking about the safety rules I remind my daughter of every time she goes out. Don’t walk alone. Watch your drink. Text me when you get there. Be careful what you wear (this one kills me to say). I hate these constant little reminders about safety that make me sound like a naggy, distrustful parent. Now listen for the second set of rules, the quieter ones that I know I have said before, and that I know she gets from every other person in her day. Smile. Be nice. Don’t make a scene. Don’t be so dramatic. Don’t hurt their feelings. 

Put them together, and here is what many girls hear: Keep yourself safe. Stay under the radar. Don’t make anyone uncomfortable.

That is an impossible job, but one that most of us have grown up with and passed on to our daughters. It’s not just about being polite. These are the rules that we hope will keep us and our daughters safe, at least that has been my intention. But the older I get, and the more I see my daughter dim her light to feel safe in her environment, the more I have questioned the entire premise of what creates safety for our daughters.

The weight we hand them

Last year both of my daughters were struggling, in separate ways, with an aggressive group of male classmates. My youngest daughter had a boy in class who would talk about her body, her weight and her figure. At one point he even touched her bottom and made her very uncomfortable. We went directly into school for a meeting and the teachers said that they had noticed it but didn’t think it was bothering her. Besides, she chose to sit on the reading rug (where she could hear better) and she knew that he sat there too. She was in third grade. We removed her from the school.

Our older daughter was dealing with boys saying ugly things to her and her friends, putting anonymous notes in her locker, and spreading rumors about her. She spoke up for herself. She reported it. The staff had seen it. Yet nothing was done. The school’s advice was to stay away from them, sit in the front of the class, don’t talk back or engage. 

Unfortunately, many of us know that this is the usual advice given to girls about negative, but seemingly harmless, actions of boys. Some of us have probably given the same advice knowing that it is unlikely that we can get someone else to stop their behavior. From a young age, girls are taught that their safety is their responsibility. They learn to read a room, to notice who is watching, to plan their exit. When something goes wrong, the first questions are often about the girl. What did she say? What was she wearing? Why was she there? Why didn’t she leave?

At the same time, we train her to soften the very voice that would protect her. A loud “No!” A sudden exit. Calling out a comment in front of others. Those feel rude, and she has learned that being rude is worse than being uncomfortable.

Ask almost any woman, and she can tell you about a time she laughed off a remark that made her skin crawl, froze when she wanted to run, or apologized to the person who crossed her line. That isn’t weakness. It’s training.

In the end, my daughter used her voice and was firm about it. “No! This is not my fault. They are responsible for their actions”. And when she abruptly got up and walked out of class my husband and I went to the school and backed her up. We supported her confrontation of the teacher who had witnessed things happen in their classroom and did nothing, and, finally, after 5-months of harassment the gears started to move. The teacher was given more training and had regular classroom observations. A boy was expelled, and the other two were removed from her class. Luckily, we had encouraged our daughter enough to advocate for herself in a loud and clear way and that she was comfortable knowing that we had her back, but I was still troubled that nothing would have been done had we not backed her up. 

What we can do

Let her be loud sometimes. When your daughter pushes back on you, she’s practicing. You can hold a limit without shaming her voice: “I get that you’re angry. Tell me more.”

Stop making her responsible for other people’s comfort. Don’t force hugs with relatives. Don’t make her apologize for saying no.

Watch your praise. Notice her ideas, effort, curiosity, and courage, not just her looks, politeness, or how helpful she is.

Teach safety as power, not blame. Try: “You deserve to be safe. If anyone hurts you, it is never your fault, and you can always tell me.”

Give boys the job, too. Keeping girls safe shouldn’t fall on girls alone. Our sons need to learn to respect, listen, and to speak up when they see or hear something happening to another. 

Look in the mirror. Moms, how do we talk about our own bodies? How often do we apologize for taking up room (my daughter calls me out on this all the time)? Dads, what do your daughters see in how you treat the women in your life? How do you communicate? It is not enough to be a silent support. Dads need to say directly how they believe girls and women should be treated, and then live up to those ideals. Children learn far more from watching than from listening.

A word of comfort

If you see yourself in this, you’re not alone. Most of us were raised on these messages and passed them along without noticing. My friends and I are consistently healing and reacting more honestly. That’s not a reason for shame. It’s a reason for curiosity. There is great power in vulnerability.

I want my daughters to know that being safe and being heard are not opposites. I want them to leave home knowing they are whole, not because someone finds them pleasing, but because they are human. Let’s raise girls who don’t have to shrink to be safe, and let’s build a world that stops asking them to.

Read more like this:

https://www.connectiveparenting.com/empowering-boys-girls-culture-sexual-harassment/

https://www.connectiveparenting.com/what-dads-teach-boys-about-women/